How to vet a known sperm donor and avoid scammers

A first-person note from Dean, a known sperm donor a short drive from Philadelphia (PHL) and Baltimore (BWI). This article is not medical or legal advice, and it is not a fertility-clinic guide.

If you are looking for a known sperm donor, you already know the internet can be a messy place to start. I have met genuine intended parents through apps, forums, and Facebook groups. I have also wasted a lot of time on people who were not who they claimed to be, including scammers. That is a large part of why I built GivingGenes.com — so the first conversation can be calmer, and so it is harder for someone to impersonate me.

This is the checklist I wish more people used before they share private details, book a trip, or agree to meet. You can use it with me or with anyone else. Go slowly. You do not owe anyone access to your life because they posted a profile.

Start with the basics, on paper

Before you message anyone, write down what you actually want. Are you a single woman, or are you part of a couple? Do you want a known donor who stays in occasional contact, or someone who stays in the background once a child has a way to reach them later? If you are considering natural insemination with a known donor, read this explanation of what NI involves first and do not let anyone rush you. Clarity about method and testing will make the first conversation better.

If two of you are deciding together, have that conversation in private before a donor is in the thread. Mixed signals are how people get hurt, and they are also how opportunistic strangers look for a gap.

Treat every profile as unverified

A complete profile is a starting point, not proof. Anyone can copy a photograph, invent a height, or claim a clean test. I publish an introduction under the name Dean and say clearly that I only use this website. You should still verify me in conversation, just as you should verify anyone else.

Look for consistency. Does the story about location, age, prior donations, or testing change when you ask twice? Does the person avoid video, or refuse ordinary questions about screening? A genuine donor can be private without being evasive. Repeated contradictions, pressure, or a sudden change of platform are reasons to pause.

Never pay someone who claims to be a donor — and be wary of anyone who asks

This is the scam I want people to hear clearly. I do not ask recipients for money, and I will not move a conversation to another website in order to collect it. I only use GivingGenes.com, including the inquiry form and the private client area on this site.

Anyone claiming to be Dean somewhere else, especially anyone asking you to send money, is an impersonator. Do not pay them. If you are unsure, come back to this site and use the official form.

The same rule is a good one with other donors. Groups are full of requests for “holds,” travel deposits, advance reimbursements, or gift cards. Logistics can be discussed after you have verified each other. A demand for payment before a real conversation is a warning sign.

Ask for current STI results, and be ready to share yours

Current sexual-health screening matters for everyone involved. A serious donor should be willing to talk about a recent panel and, when the conversation is real, share results privately. Both parties should complete current testing and exchange those results before any meeting.

When you look at a panel, look at the date, the person’s name, and what was actually tested. A screenshot with no name and no date is not enough. My own public page lists the date of my most recent panel and what it included; I can share the documents privately with serious inquiries. You should still get your own current tests. A past result does not speak for today, and nothing on a website is a medical clearance.

If you want a fuller list of questions — including family history — I wrote Questions to ask a known sperm donor.

Meet carefully, and keep your first meeting ordinary

If you decide to meet, meet in a public place first. Control your own travel, and tell a trusted person where you are going. You do not need to publish your hotel or your routine to someone you have only just started talking to.

If you would be flying in, I wrote a separate note on planning a trip to meet a donor near PHL or BWI. If you are just starting to look, how to find a known sperm donor and is a known sperm donor free? may help first. If you are looking from this region, there are also short guides for Pennsylvania, Maryland, Delaware and the Mid-Atlantic, and New Jersey. Do not travel until identity and testing have been discussed, and do not go straight from the airport to a private home.

Video calls help. More than one conversation helps. A person who is real can usually tolerate a careful pace.

Watch for pressure and mixed motives

You should be clear about what you want. Be cautious of anyone who pushes past your stated method, teases intimacy as a condition of “helping,” or becomes angry when you ask ordinary safety questions.

It is also fair for a donor to decline an inquiry that is not a fit. “No” is part of a careful process. Ghosting after a scheduled meeting is inconsiderate; disappearing because you are uncomfortable is sometimes the safest choice. If you cancel, a short, civil message is enough.

A simple rule for contacting me

If you found a profile, a message, or a website that uses my name and it is not GivingGenes.com, treat it as fake until you have checked this site. Read the expectations, then send a thoughtful note through the inquiry form if you still want to talk. One-line messages usually are not enough, and that is deliberate. I would rather hear from people who are serious about having a child and willing to proceed carefully.

Not medical or legal advice. I am committed until we succeed, and with my experience, it is likely that we will.

Start an inquiry · All guides